Making Fines Fair
HHRay and I got into a debate today. We talked about demerit points and fines for getting caught for irresponsible driving of some sort – drunk driving, speeding, etc etc. Something you’re not allowed to do on the road. We started talking about fines and how they impact wealthy and poor people. Say the set fine for some kind of misbehavior is $500. And every person they stop for that misbehavior has to pay $500. Well, some poor person will pay that $500 and not be able to pay his rent next week. A millionaire pays $500 and commits the same thing the next day because $500 out of his pocket, to him, is nothing. So poor people are impacted greatly by that fine and rich people don’t think twice about it. How is that helping? It’s just telling us that rich people can get away with more than poor people can.
I suggested that maybe there should be a fine based on a percentage instead of a static amount of dollars. For example, say the amount the person would have to pay might be 0.08% of his annual income or something (this is just a random figure, used as an example only). This way, the amount of money which people of all types of income will pay would have the same impact instead of seeming like a mountain to one person and a molehill to another. It’ll be fair.
Why wouldn’t this work? HHRay said that rich people would never allow this to happen, that it would be unfair to them. But come on, don’t you think that the way things are set out now is unfair to poor people? My suggested payment amount modification would put everyone on the same level – nobody will have to pay more than they can afford while their rich neighbor pays the same amount and doesn’t even get a dent in his wallet. Yes, wealthy people would have to adjust, but they’d be adjusting to a more fair system than the one that we have now.
Everybody’s debating about The Golden Compass. Christians have been attempting to halt the release and convince people to refuse to see the movie, raising their holy voices and screaming at anything they think might listen that the movie is outrageous, anti-Christian, blasphemous, and so on and so forth.